Tracy’s Dilemma, Chapter 11

  • Posted on January 15, 2018 at 8:52 am

By Cheryl Taggert

Laura was excited. The new girl on the swim team, Corinne, had accepted her invitation to spend the night. She was beautiful, a natural redhead, with emerald eyes that seemed to convey a sense of sexuality. Of course, Laura had no idea if Corinne liked sex or not, but she was hoping to find out.

Laura had watched Corinne when they were in the locker room changing into their swimsuits, as well as when they were showering off the chlorinated water. Corinne’s red patch of pubic hair stood out in the sea of black and blonde pubic hair of the rest of the girls. Laura noticed she was not the only girl checking out Corinne’s slender nudity and red pubes. Of course, Emily, Kelli and Kate did, but she counted more than a half dozen other girls who would surreptitiously glance up and down the girl’s body.

More than once, Laura had masturbated to images of her and Corinne together in bed. The sleepover was the first step. Emily had agreed to sleep on the sofa, fully aware of Laura’s intentions and wanting to allow her big sister to complete the seduction.

She had discussed her crush with her mom, of course. Sandra listened, her smile matching Laura’s, as her daughter gushed over the girl.

“Do you think she would be interested in sex?” Laura had asked.

“Honey, she’s fourteen. Of course, she’s interested in sex. It’s kind of a requirement of being an official teenager. The question is, would she be interested in sex with you?”

Laura sighed in exasperation. “Okay, fine. Do you think she’d be interested in sex with me?”

“I have no idea why you’re asking me. I’ve seen her but never even spoken to her, but what’s your plan of seduction?”

“Huh?”

“How do you plan to get her interested in doing something? It might only be masturbation together in your bed, but you should aim to start with something simple like that. I can tell you when I was your age, that would have been a lot less frightening than actually having sex with another girl.”

Laura considered her mother’s advice, and although she wanted to get her lips on Corinne’s pussy lips, she decided mutual masturbation might be all she could hope for this time. That could lead to more later. She had no idea how she might seduce her friend, but she thought something would come up if she tried to steer the conversation to sexual topics.

The evening of the sleepover finally arrived. Laura felt her heartbeat speed up when the doorbell rang, and she noticed both Emily and her mom smiling knowingly as Laura raced to the door.

Throwing it open, she was met by Corinne’ smiling face. “Hey!” Laura said, stepping back to allow the girl to enter. Corinne walked through the door and Laura hugged her as Corinne dropped her small overnight bag to embrace her new friend.

“Hey, yourself,” Corinne said.

As Corinne looked around the room as they hugged, she saw Laura’s younger sister and mom grinning at the two embracing girls. Corinne had noticed the attention she was getting from her teammates. She loved being admired in this way because she had been a pudgy girl before she reached puberty and began to grow taller and filling out some. Nobody had ever looked at her back then in the way they did now. She was aware she was turning into a beauty, and she relished that other people noticed, too. It had been a year ago when she’d first noticed the attention. A boy in her class at the school where she’d gone before her dad’s job required the move to this new town had asked her out and it was the first time she decided to take a new look at herself. She had gone home from school that day and undressed in front of the full-length mirror in her parents’ bedroom. She noticed that the baby fat that had been a part of her life for as long as she could remember was disappearing. She’d taken up swimming, and she wondered how much the activity had to do with the changes she saw that day for the first time.

What surprised her most of all, though, was the fact that staring at her naked body had turned her on. She had discovered masturbation when she was ten and had explored her bare pussy for the millionth time, enjoying the sensations until those sensations became nearly unbearable. Something inside told her to keep going since it felt so good, and at a point her insides seemed to explode into a state of sheer amazement at the feelings that spread throughout her young, chubby body. She had always noticed how good it felt to touch herself down there, but this was the first time it had felt . . . amazing. She did the same thing the next day, with the same result. In fact, she enjoyed looking at herself so much that she liked to use a hand mirror to watch herself masturbate sometimes.

Now, getting herself off had become a daily ritual, a private activity she managed to enjoy at least once during the day. She had not had an opportunity to come today, and she secretly hoped the sleepover might turn into something more sexual. Perhaps when they talked about boys, as they inevitably would, Laura would admit to being horny sometimes. Maybe, Corinne thought, she might be able to convince her new friend to masturbate with her. If not, she would wait until Laura was asleep and take care of things then. If Laura’s sleep seemed reluctant to arrive, she could excuse herself to the bathroom, where she would take care of herself and her daily need.

Laura could feel her friend’s small boobs pressing against her own as they hugged. She was so turned on, she wanted to push the girl to the floor right then and there and have sex with her, but of course she didn’t. First of all, Corinne would undoubtedly freak out and run screaming from the house, and second, Laura’s brother was sitting on the nearby couch reading a book. Laura noticed the look he gave Corinne, one of desire, and she thought to herself, Hands off, big brother. This one’s mine.

The embrace had lasted only a few seconds, and when the girls parted, Laura noticed the slight blush in Corinne’s cheeks. She wondered what might have put it there.

“Laura, show Corinne where your bedroom is so she can put her overnight bag somewhere other than in the family room,” Sandra said to her daughter.

“Oh! Sure,” Laura said, and turned to Corinne. “This way.” Corinne followed Laura down the hallway to the bedroom. She immediately realized that two girls lived in the room. She recognized some of Emily’s belongings she had seen at school. Her book bag was at one of the two small desks in the room, along with a separate closet for her clothes.

“You and your sister share a room?” Corinne asked.

“Yeah. But don’t worry. She’s sleeping on the sofa tonight. We’ll be able to stay up and talk and enjoy each ourselves without her being in here.”

Corinne wondered about the phrasing Laura had used. ‘Enjoy ourselves’? She felt her heart take a sudden leap at the possible meaning. Was she lucky enough to have Laura imagining the same things she had? That they might masturbate together? Her mouth went dry at the thought.

“I’m sorry Emily has to sleep on the sofa,” Corinne said. “I didn’t realize she might be put out by my staying here tonight.”

“Don’t worry about it. I sleep on the sofa when she has a friend over. We’re used to it.”

Corinne smiled. “Okay. As long as she doesn’t mind.”

“She doesn’t. She’s about as happy you’re here as I am.”

The girls looked at each other again, and Corinne felt herself blush before she looked away.

“C’mon. Let’s get a Coke and watch something on the TV,” Laura said.

“Sure! Do you have Netflix?”

“Who doesn’t? Whatcha wanna watch on it? Any current faves?”

Corinne’s blush deepened. “Well, my parents like to watch something that I’ve wanted to watch, but I’m not allowed. I was kinda wondering if we might could watch it here. To be honest, I don’t really even know what it’s about other than they like it and won’t let me watch it. I promise my folks won’t ever find out.”

Laura was intrigued. She wondered if it was a show with some sex in it. Why else would Corinne’s parents not want her to watch it? “What’s the show?”

“Orange is the New Black?” Corinne said, unsure if they would be allowed to watch it.

Laura’s jaw dropped. Was she kidding? Could she be this fortunate? Her friend wanted to watch a show that featured . . . lesbianism?

“You’ve never seen it?”

“No.”

“And you don’t know what it’s about?”

“Nuh-uh.”

“Holy shit! It’s about a woman who goes to prison. That’s sorta where they get the title, you know? All the women are wearing these orange jumpsuit things.”

“Oh. Can we watch it?”

“Corinne? Do you know what women do in prison?”

Corinne looked confused. “What d’ya mean?”

“Like, you know, for sex.”

Corinne’s mouth dropped open. “You mean it’s about lesbians?”

“Yeah.”

Corinne wondered where watching a program like that might lead. She also thought about how much her mom seemed to like the show. What was that about? She wanted to masturbate together with Laura, but the idea of actually doing something with each other had not really occurred to her. Suddenly, the idea of having someone else touch her pussy, namely Laura, turned her on.

“Have you watched it?” Corinne asked.

“Sure. It’s a cool show.” Laura didn’t want to give away that she had enjoyed the girl-girl scenes, as mild as they were. The idea of watching the show made her realize that this was perfect. It would open up a discussion about lesbian sex when they went to bed that night.

“Would it be possible for us to watch it alone? You know, without everyone in the room knowing we were seeing the women have sex? That would be too embarrassing.”

“Well, my dad’s out of town on business, and my brother is staying the night with his best friend, so it will only be us and my mom and Emily.”

“What about your mom? Would she be okay with us watching something like that together? I mean, we’re sleeping in the same bed tonight, and I wouldn’t want her to start thinking we might do something.”

Laura felt a sudden drop of her enthusiasm when she heard that. It suggested Corinne wouldn’t be interested in lesbian sex for real. Still, she decided to go ahead and see if the show might change her mind. “My mom’s fine with it. Em and me can watch whatever we want on Netflix.”

“Wow, that’s so cool. I wish my parents were like that. Well, let’s wait ’til your brother leaves. I’d be mortified if some sex came on the screen and he was there.”

“Sure. He’ll be gone soon, I’m sure.”

The girls went into the kitchen to pour themselves some Coke on ice. While they prepared the drinks, Tad, Laura’s older brother, came in and said he was leaving. It was obvious he wasn’t coming to tell them so he could see his sisters. Laura noticed his eyes rake over Corinne, and she scowled at him as he left.

As soon as he was gone, Laura asked her mom if they could watch Netflix.

“Sure.”

The girls went into the family room and turned on the TV, tuning in to Netflix. Emily joined them. “Okay if I watch with you?”

Laura glanced at Corinne to see if she was fine with being joined by her little sister. Corinne, seeing the look, shrugged an ‘it’s okay with me’ to Laura.

“Sure. We’re gonna watch Orange Is the New Black.” Laura sneaked a smile at Emily, who smiled back. “Corinne’s never seen it before, so we’re starting with episode one.”

“Cool,” Emily said, and settled into an armchair facing the TV, draping one leg over the padded arm. Corinne looked Emily’s way and saw that her panties were clearly visible through the open leg hole of her short shorts.

When the scene began with Piper and her fiance, Corinne said, “I thought this was about lesbian sex.”

Emily giggled. “It is,” she said, “but it’s not like porn or anything, so don’t get your hopes up too high.”

Corinne looked at Emily. “I’m not getting my hopes up!” She blushed, wondering if she was being that obvious. “You’ve seen porn before?”

“Sure. Who hasn’t?” Emily answered.

Corinne didn’t answer. She had never seen any porn, but she wanted to. Her parents monitored her use of the internet. Their computer was set up to open a screen with a password only her parents knew, and they would never allow her online unless they were in the family room, where the computer was kept where anyone in the room could see the screen. She thought her parents were paranoid, but they were right that she’d be looking at things they didn’t want her to see if she were allowed to get online when alone. Still, all her friends had some private time on computers, and they weren’t running wild or getting in trouble with the police or anything. It was unfair!

When the episode had finished, she was disappointed that no nudity had happened beyond seeing a woman from the side near the end of the episode, but even then a hand was covering her breast so all you could see was some side boob. There was sex, but you really couldn’t see anything that was happening.

“There wasn’t any nudity,” Corinne said. The sisters could tell she was disappointed.

“There’s a lot of things on here with nudity,” Laura said. “Of course, there’s even more online,” she added, winking at Corinne.

Corinne looked down at the floor before cutting her eyes to where Emily sat, her panties still in plain view. “I’ve never . . . I mean, my parents don’t allow me to get online without them in the room.”

Laura’s mouth dropped open. “You’ve never seen any porn?”

“No.” She looked at the surprised faces of the sisters.

“Do you want to?” Emily asked.

Corinne’s face turned as red as her hair. “Sure.”

“Hold on a sec’,” Laura said and rose from the sofa and went in search of her mom. She found her in her bedroom, re-arranging her closet.

“Mom?”

“What is it, honey?”

“Is it okay if I take Corinne into the bedroom to watch some porn online? She’s never seen it before.”

Sandra looked at her daughter. “Well, I see you figured out your seduction plan.” She smiled at her daughter and hugged her. “Don’t get too loud. You don’t want to give away that we’re involved like that.”

“Sure. I just didn’t want you walking in on us or anything.”

“Have fun. Will Emily be with you?”

“Probably. I can’t imagine her letting us watch porn together without joining in.”

Laura returned to the family room and said, “Let’s all go to our bedroom.”

“What about your mom?”

“She knows not to come barging in on us. She allows us our privacy because, well, she knows we might not be dressed and all. Like I said, she’s very liberal about stuff like that.”

Corinne took this to mean their mother was aware they masturbated, which was good news. She again wondered where watching online porn might lead.

When they entered the bedroom, Laura locked the door for show. Then she took her seat in front of their computer and booted up. Emily pulled her chair over next to Laura’s and indicated that Corinne should sit there.

“What about you?” Corinne asked. “Are you going to watch too?”

“Of course, but I can stand behind y’all or sit on the end of the bed here,” Emily said.

Corinne took the seat and watched as Laura opened a site called Pornhub. Laura glanced at Corinne. “So, you wanna watch some lesbians or straight?”

“They have both?” Corinne asked, amazed that such things were out there for her to enjoy if only her parents would buy her a computer for her room.

“Sure, silly,” Emily said. “There’s even gay sex with guys.”

Corinne liked boys but wasn’t interested in watching them have sex with each other. She was unsure how to answer. She wanted to watch lesbians, but she didn’t want to say so. “You choose. It’s your computer.”

Laura shrugged. “Well, you obviously were disappointed there wasn’t any real lesbian sex in the show, so let’s look at that, okay?”

Corinne shrugged as well, not wanting the sisters to know that was what she hoped they would watch, and said, “Sex is sex. I just want to see people doing it.”

Laura clicked the search box and entered ‘lesbian’ there, pressing the enter key and watching the small pictures from the videos with brief, descriptive titles fill the screen. She saw one she liked called “Are you turned on?” She smiled and clicked on it. It was the perfect clip for them to watch, about two friends having a sleepover and getting involved, beginning with one character suggesting they just “help each other out.” As the video opened, she hoped she wasn’t being too obvious.

As the three girls watched, they became totally silent. Only their heavy breathing could be heard. Within less than a minute, Corinne was wondering if Laura had chosen this video on purpose since it involved two girls having a sleepover and getting horny. Was she suggesting they ‘help each other out’ the way it was happening in the video?

After one girl began rubbing the other beneath the covers on the bed, she started to wonder if that would be all they would see. She was both turned on and disappointed at the same time. She wanted to see exactly what was happening, and since it was happening where they couldn’t see it, she wondered if this would just tease them. After all, the girls could just be faking it. She’d heard that porn was real sex, not just simulation.

Then the girls were kissing, and there was a shot of the blond touching the other girl’s pussy through her shorts and panties. That was better, but she wanted more.

When the blond girl started licking and sucking the brunette’s nipples, she realized they would probably be seeing a lot more soon. She felt a small shudder run through her as the women began doing more to each other. They were really turned on, not just faking it.

“Oh my God!” Corinne breathed, feeling her pussy beginning to soak her panties.

Corinne was totally focused on the action on the computer screen and didn’t notice Laura and Emily exchange a glance. Laura grinned at Emily and nodded down at Emily’s pussy, her meaning clear.

Emily raised her eyebrows as if to ask if her sister was sure they wanted to move things along that quickly. Laura nodded before turning her attention back to the computer.

Several minutes passed, and the girls on the screen were getting more involved. When the brunette removed the blond’s pajama bottoms, revealing the thong that barely covered the blond’s pussy, its thin string running from the tiny patch of material along her ass crack, Corinne realized it was about to get really interesting. The blond’s pussy was clearly visible and the brunette leaned down and began licking the blond’s pussy.

Corinne heard a brief gasp behind her and glanced back at Emily. The younger girl was standing behind and between Laura and Corinne. Her hand was inside her shorts, but still outside her panties. She knew this because the waistline of the panties were behind her wrist.

She shuddered as she realized Laura’s little sister was masturbating right there in front of them. Well, really behind them, Corinne thought, but still in front of them in a different sense.

She looked up at Emily, who was smiling down at her. “Hey, if it feels good, do it, right?”

Corinne looked at Laura, wondering how she was taking it that Emily was playing with herself right there. Laura was grinning at her. “You don’t mind, do you? You can do it, too, if you want. I don’t know about you, but there’s no way I can watch something sexy like this and not get myself off.”

Movement from Emily made Corinne look back at her. The young girl was pulling her shirt over her head before she reached down to take her shorts and panties off. Within seconds, the girl was standing behind them, naked. Corinne had seen her naked before in the girls’ locker room at swim meets and practice, but this was different. This wasn’t just Emily naked. This was Emily naked and horny. Then as she watched, it became Emily rubbing her wet slit.

Corinne felt herself blush, more from desire than embarrassment. She noticed Laura moving, and she was lifting her butt from the chair and pulling her own shorts and panties down before lifting her shirt over her head. Now the sisters were both naked. She was the only one in the room with any clothes on. Should she join them? she wondered. She knew she would need to come, and this was what she had hoped would happen, but now that it was actually taking place, her nervousness was causing her to hesitate. She had never masturbated in front of anyone else before. Her own fantasies about this sleepover involved her and Laura in bed beneath the covers, touching themselves but not in full view of each other.

She couldn’t decide if this were better or not. It seemed to require more of a commitment from her.

She looked back at the computer screen, where the sisters were now focused. The brunette had removed the blond’s panties and was licking the girl’s pussy. The blond was nearly panting with desire. It was obvious she wasn’t acting. The girl was near an orgasm.

A small spasm in her panties let Corinne know she was going to come whether or not she touched her pussy. She realized that if she didn’t join Laura and Emily, they might be ashamed after they finished, thinking she was not happy this had happened. It might end up being the last time she got together with either of them.

She lifted her shirt over her head, unclasped her bra and let it tumble to the floor. Corinne noticed Laura glance over at her with approval as she lifted her butt and pulled her shorts and panties down, joining the sisters to be nude in the locked bedroom.

Then the blond in the movie was coming, shuddering and pressing her pussy against the brunette’s hungry mouth. It was too much for Corinne, she reached down and started rubbing herself, the orgasm taking over her body within seconds.

She remained as quiet as she could while she came, not wanting to take the chance that her friends’ mother might hear them. She figured for all the woman knew, the girls were just sitting in the room and talking.

What she didn’t know was that Sandra had stepped quietly along the carpeted hallway to the bedroom door minutes after Laura had locked it. She stood listening to the girls as they listened to the online porn. The girls were quiet until she heard Emily say something about how if it felt good, do it. She knew then Emily was rubbing herself. Sandra reached down to her own pussy and began stroking her wet cunt.

Laura watched, fascinated, as Corinne reached her orgasm. Only the nearly silent grunting breaths and jerky shuddering gave away that she was coming. Corinne leaned forward, hunching over with the intensity of her climax while keeping her fingers on her sensitive flesh, drawing out the wonderful feelings that enveloped her.

Sandra, her ear pressed to the door, could hear the small moans as Corinne came. At this point, her own shudders took over and she was coming, doing her best to be even more quiet than the girls. She could barely hear the sounds from the computer, so it was easy to tell this was one of the girls in the room who was coming, not one of the girl in the video.

Her orgasm subsided and she tip-toed away from the door, her fingers inside her mouth where she sucked her juices from them.

Inside the bedroom, Emily was the next to reach her climax. She was a bit more vocal than Corinne had been, and Laura shushed her. After her orgasm, when Laura said, “Mom might hear you!” she glanced at Laura with a ‘so what’ obvious on her face, until she realized they were playing the part of girls who didn’t actually have incestuous, lesbian sex with their mother.

Corinne noticed the odd exchange but said nothing, wondering what it meant. Emily didn’t look the least bit concerned that her mom might hear them masturbating in the bedroom. What was that all about? Were the girls allowed to be open about their fun? Were the sisters more than just masturbation mates? She wasn’t stupid. She knew that a lot of sisters their age would, as the movie had put it, ‘help each other out.’ Had Emily and Laura done that? Had they done what the two beautiful girls in the video were doing? Had they actually licked each other’s pussy?

The thought of that made her pussy twinge again with sudden lust, and the response surprised her. She realized she wanted the answers to the questions she asked herself to be yes. The idea of watching them together made her reach down and once again begin playing with herself.

Laura re-doubled her efforts as Corinne returned to her erotic activity. She rubbed the cream that seemed to be gushing from her vagina all around her inner labia, relishing the slick feel of her fingers gliding over her clit, sending tingling thrills throughout her body.

Beside Laura, Corinne’s breath started a staccato of sharp exhales. “Huh . . . huh . . . huh” burst from Corinne as the girl reached another quick climax.

Laura couldn’t wait any longer. Her pussy began to spasm, rocking her hips up and down from the seat as the orgasm consumed her. She came with an intensity that seemed to shake her entire body. Suddenly she smelled Emily’s pussy, and she realized her sister had clamped her hand over her mouth. Her sister’s fingers were still wet from her pussy. Had she been screaming?

Without thinking, and seemingly unaware of their situation that another girl was in the room, Laura pushed her tongue out and began licking Emily’s pussy juices from her fingers. She leaned forward, taking two of Emily’s come covered fingers into her mouth and began sucking, all while continuing one of the most powerful orgasms of her life.

As Laura’s intense climax began to subside, she remembered Corinne. She had become momentarily so involved in the orgasm, she forgot they weren’t alone. She stopped what she was doing, and looked over at her new friend, hoping she wasn’t making a disgusted face.

What she saw wasn’t a look of disgust, but she couldn’t tell exactly what it was. Her eyes were wide, either in disbelief or fascination–or perhaps both.

As Emily’s fingers slid from her mouth, Laura wondered what would happen then. She half expected Corinne to rise quickly from the chair and wordlessly get dressed before rushing out the door of the bedroom and demanding to be taken home.

Instead, Corinne said, “You do,” and her mouth dropped open.

Corinne glanced up at Emily, to see her reaction to what her sister had done. She wasn’t shocked. She looked more embarrassed than anything. She looked back at Laura and repeated herself. “You really do.”

Laura, knowing the answer to her question, asked it anyway.

“I really do–what?”

“You guys have sex together,” Corinne said. “Like those girls in the video.” She glanced at the screen, but the video had ended.

Laura looked frantic. There was no sense in denying it. She had taken her sister’s creamy fingers into her mouth with familiarity. It was obvious she had done that before. “Please don’t tell anyone! Our lives would be over!”

Corinne hadn’t even considered doing such a thing. No, she had been thinking about that night instead. The image of the sisters together had brought on her latest orgasm. She wanted to see it in real life, not just her imagination.

“I’d never tell a soul,” Corinne said. “But–” she hesitated before saying what she wanted so badly to say. “But can I watch you two together?”

Continue on to Chapter 12

8 Comments on Tracy’s Dilemma, Chapter 11

  1. Amanda Lynn says:

    Wonderful to see another steamy chapter. Welcome back, Cheryl. Oh, and the link was a nice touch too.

  2. robt66 says:

    That was super super hot Cheryl. I really hope this is a sign of recovery for you.

  3. Andrea says:

    Love the link too. Mmm that brunette! She got all disheveled. :)

  4. kacey says:

    Hey Cheryl. Welcome back to the fold. That was, yet another,fabulously hot chapter! :-D Looking forward to ch.12 :-)

  5. JetBoy says:

    Damn, do I ever love this story! Cheryl, be assured that current tribulations have done nothing whatsoever to diminish your erotic gifts. Hotter than five-alarm chili!

  6. Jordan denton says:

    Can’t wait for the next instalment

  7. Tim says:

    Another wonderful chapter Cheryl.
    Just so descriptive and arousing.
    Thanks for brightening my morning!!!

Leave a Reply